- Open Access
Derivation of chicken induced pluripotent stem cells tolerant to Newcastle disease virus-induced lysis through multiple rounds of infection
Virology Journal volume 13, Article number: 205 (2016)
Newcastle disease (ND), caused by Newcastle disease virus (NDV), is a devastating disease of poultry and wild birds. ND is prevented by rigorous biocontainment and vaccination. One potential approach to prevent spread of the virus is production of birds that show innate resistance to NDV-caused disease. Induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) technology allows adult cells to be reprogrammed into an embryonic stem cell-like state capable of contributing to live offspring and passing on unique traits in a number of species. Recently, iPSC approaches have been successfully applied to avian cells. If chicken induced pluripotent stem cells (ciPSCs) are genetically or epigenetically modified to resist NDV infection, it may be possible to generate ND resistant poultry. There is limited information on the potential of ciPSCs to be infected by NDV, or the capacity of these cells to become resistant to infection. The aim of the present work was to assess the characteristics of the interaction between NDV and ciPSCs, and to develop a selection method that would increase tolerance of these cells to NDV-induced cellular damage.
Results showed that ciPSCs were permissive to infection with NDV, and susceptible to virus-mediated cell death. Since ciPSCs that survived infection demonstrated the ability to recover quickly, we devised a system to select surviving cells through multiple infection rounds with NDV. ciPSCs that sustained 9 consecutive infections had a statistically significant increase in survival (up to 36 times) compared to never-infected ciPSCs upon NDV infection (tolerant cells). Increased survival was not caused by a loss of permissiveness to NDV replication. RNA sequencing followed by enrichment pathway analysis showed that numerous metabolic pathways where differentially regulated between tolerant and never-infected ciPSCs.
Results demonstrate that ciPSCs are permissive to NDV infection and become increasingly tolerant to NDV under selective pressure, indicating that this system could be applied to study mechanisms of cellular tolerance to NDV.
Newcastle disease (ND) is a devastating disease of domestic poultry that causes severe economic losses both in developing and developed countries . The disease is caused by virulent strains of Newcastle disease virus (NDV), an enveloped virus classified within the Mononegavirales order, Paramyxoviridae family, Avulavirus genus . All NDV strains belong to a single serotype (avian paramyxovirus serotype 1, APMV-1), and the virus genome constitutes of a non-segmented, negative sense RNA molecule of approximately 15.2 Kb, which encodes for six structural proteins, namely from 3’ to 5’: nucleoprotein (NP), phosphoprotein (P), matrix (M), fusion (F), hemagglutinin-neuraminidase (HN), and polymerase (L) . According to international standards, NDV strains can be classified as virulent or non-virulent, based on the intra cerebral pathogenicity index (ICPI), and on the deduced amino acid sequence of the F protein at amino acid residues 112 to 117 (cleavage site) .
Worldwide control of ND is carried out by costly and rigorous biocontainment and vaccination programs . NDV vaccines protect birds against clinical signs, however do not confer sterile immunity, leading to circulation of virulent strains among vaccinated birds [5, 6]. Unrestrained virus circulation leads to virus evolution and ultimately emergence of new NDV strains . Attempts to select for resistance against NDV in poultry through traditional breeding strategies have not been successful , and to date no poultry species susceptible to NDV have been successfully bred for increased resistance against development of ND. Production of poultry species that are resistant to NDV infection at the cellular level could hypothetically lead to the development of new means of controlling ND, especially in areas where ND is endemic and difficult to eradicate.
Induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) technology is a system by which adult cells such as skin fibroblast can be reprogrammed into an embryonic state, almost identical to embryonic stem cells. iPSCs can be utilized to generate animals with unique genetic and epigenetic traits as they can form germline competent chimeric animals and ultimately offspring with the specified phenotypes [9, 10]. iPSC technology has been successfully applied to mammalian species, including humans [9–12], and it has garnered success with avian species as well, such as chickens and quails [13–15]. Chicken induced pluripotent stem cells (ciPSCs) display characteristics indicative of a stem cell state including morphological and functional characteristic [13, 14, 16]. ciPSCs have demonstrable alkaline phosphatase enzymatic activity, and positive cytochemical staining for periodic acid-schiff (PAS) [13, 14, 16], consistent with stem cell staining characteristics . As the most stringent proof of pluripotency, ciPSCs can be used to generate chimeric birds by transplantation into the embryo at early stages of embryogenesis, as shown with chicken-quails and chicken-chicken chimeras [13, 14]. Chimeric animals can then be bred to produce offspring with specific traits, as demonstrated by our group in other livestock species [15, 18]. Further, our laboratory has demonstrated that ciPSCs can undergo in vitro differentiation into early primordial germ cells (PGCs), which are capable of migrating to the gonads when injected into a developing embryo . These ciPSC-PGCs can produce viable spermatozoa or oocytes, potentially leading to generation of fully transgenic offspring though crossbreeding of chimeric birds. With a similar mechanism, ciPSCs that are resistant to NDV could be used to generate transgenic birds that maintain the resistance trait in every tissue of the body.
Complete cellular resistance to NDV infection has been demonstrated in mammalian cells lacking specific sialylated moieties (mainly gangliosides, and N-syalilated glycoproteins) on the cell surface (absence of receptors) , while increased tolerance to NDV-induced cell death in cell culture has been associated with the presence of specific intracellular pathogen sensors – such as Retinoic Acid-Inducible Gene I (RIG-I) [21, 22]; increased type-I interferon response [23, 24]; and activity of the Mx protein family [25–27]. Also viral interference, although not a cellular resistance per se, inhibits NDV superinfection [28–30]. For the purposes of this study, the term tolerance was defined as the decreased susceptibility of ciPSCs to NDV-induced cell death, while still permissive to infection. In this context, “tolerance” differs from “resistance” to virus infection, which is considered as the total inability of the virus to infect cells (true resistance, receptor-mediated).
Infection of non-pluripotent cell lines with viruses at high multiplicity - without prior mutagenesis approach - has led to spontaneous selection of cells that are resistant or less susceptible to the cytolytic effect of the challenge virus. This has been reported for murine FM3A cells infected with NDV , porcine kidney cells line (ESK-R) infected with Influenza Virus ; hamster BHK-21 or CHO-K1 cells infected with murine encephalomyelitis virus or Ebola virus, respectively [33, 34]; canine (MDCK), swine (PK-15) and rabbit (RK-13) cell lines infected with cytolytic strains of Bovine Viral Diarrhea Virus (BVDV) . A similar approach could theoretically produce spontaneously-induced resistance in ciPSCs, or generate ciPSCs less susceptible (tolerant) to NDV-induced cellular damage.
The aim of the present work was to evaluate the susceptibility of ciPSCs to infection with NDV of different virulence, and to establish a screening/selection method to naturally derive ciPSCs that are tolerant to NDV infection. Preliminary characterization of the interaction between NDV and ciPSCs, as well as investigation into the mechanisms of resistance, offers the opportunity to better characterize these cells and fits within the overarching effort to generate ND-resistant chickens.
NDV replicates in ciPSCs
Chicken iPSCs were derived as previously described . ciPSCs had typical characteristics of a stem cell fate: large nucleus to cytoplasm ratio, large nucleoli, positive cytochemical reaction for PAS and Alkaline Phosphatase, and expression of embryonic stem cell markers as shown by RT-PCR and immunocytochemistry . Derived cells were named BA3NI, and expanded for the purpose of the experiments in this work.
To evaluate the ability of NDV to replicate in ciPSCs, multi-cycle virus growth curves were performed in BA3NI cells infected with both non-virulent (recombinant LaSota-RFP, (rLS-RFP) ) and virulent recombinant ZJ1-GFP (rZJ1-GFP)  NDV strains, and compared to growth in DF-1 cells (immortalized chicken fibroblast cells ). Briefly, both BA3NI and DF-1 cells were plated into 6-well-plates and infected with each virus at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 0.01. Virus growth at established time points [6, 12, 24, 36, 48, 72 h post-infection (hpi)] was measured by titration of the virus in the supernatant through limiting dilution using DF-1 cells, and expressed as Tissue Culture Infectious Dose 50% (TCID50)/ml. Titration results (Fig. 1, panel a and b) showed that the two viruses grew similarly in both ciPSCs and DF-1 cells up to 48 hpi, however, at 72 hpi rZJ1-GFP strain grew at significantly higher titers in ciPSCs compared to DF-1 cells (two-way ANOVA, Sidak’s test for multiple comparisons). As expected, the virulent strain showed a higher yield (2–3 logarithmic units) than the non-virulent strain in the same cell line. At 72 hpi, yields (mean ± SD, expressed as log10 TCID50 units/ml) in ciPSCs were 8.4 (+0.08, −0.10) and 5.36 (+0.22, −0.30) for rZJ1-GFP and rLS-RFP, respectively, while for DF-1 cells were 7.57 (+0.13, −0.17) and 5.32 (+0.25, −0.39) for rZJ1-GFP and rLS-RFP, respectively. Taken together, these data show that NDV is able to replicate in pluripotent BA3NI cells, slightly more efficiently than in DF-1 cells.
NDV effectively induces cell death in ciPSCs
The ability of the non-virulent rLS-RFP to induce cell death in BA3NI was assessed utilizing a high MOI. Briefly, BA3NI were plated at a density of 1.6×105 cells/well in a 6-well-plate (time point: D-1) and the following day (24 h) infected with rLS-RFP at MOI = 50 (time point: D0). At 24 hpi, cells started showing severe cytopathic effect characterized by rounding and detachment from the plate (Fig. 2, panel a), which progressed at 72 hpi (Fig. 2, panel b). These changes were associated with intense fluorescence at 24 hpi (Fig. 2, panel c), which subsided at 72 hpi in viable cells (Fig. 2, panel d). Surviving cells at 72 hpi showed no signs of cytopathic effect, although some residual fluorescence could be observed (Fig. 2, panels i–j). A representative count of infected BA3NI cells compared to non-infected cells at 72 hpi (time point: D3) is presented (Fig. 2, panel k).
Based on five biological replicates, the percentage of viable BA3NI cells after infection, as counted at 72 hpi, was 15.52% ± 10.50 (mean ± SD) of the number of cells counted at the time of infection (D0), and 2.02% ± 2.25% (mean ± SD) of the control (non-infected) cells at D3 (72 hpi). Taken together, these data show that high MOI of rLS-RFP can be used to effectively induce cell death and select BA3NI cells.
ciPSCs demonstrate rapid recovery after infection with NDV
The ability of BA3NI to recover after infection was assessed by counting the amount of viable cells at day 6 post-infection (144 hpi). BA3NI and DF-1 were plated into 6-well plates and infected at high MOI as described in the previous section. The number of viable cells present in the plate after infection was counted at 72 hpi and 144 hpi. Results showed that BA3NI and DF-1 cells recover at very different rates after infection. After markedly declining in number at 72 hpi, BA3NI cells were able to clear the virus and to proliferate as single large colonies that eventually became confluent by 144 hpi (Fig. 3, panel a). Conversely, DF-1 cells failed to recover and proliferate by 144 hpi (Fig. 3, panel c). Additionally, ciPSCs were able to clear the RFP fluorescence (Fig. 3, panel b), whereas DF-1 remained intensely fluorescent (Fig. 3, panel d). A representative count of the differences in recovery abilities between BA3NI and DF-1 is reported in (Fig. 3, panel e).
Repeated NDV selection decreases susceptibility of ciPSC to NDV-induced cell death
Given the ability of ciPSCs to be infected by NDV and to quickly recover after infection, a screening system was devised to test the hypothesis that ciPSCs could become incrementally more tolerant (less susceptible) to NDV-induced cell death upon multiple rounds of infection/selection. Tolerance, for the purpose of our study, is a quantitative character assessed in a population of infected cells, and it is quantified by calculating the ratio between amount of viable cells present at 72 hpi (D3) and those present at the time of infection (0 h, D0); the higher the ratio, the more tolerant cells are deemed. Therefore, increased tolerance encompasses both the ability of cells to withstand virus-induced cell death, and to recover from it (clearing the infection and replicating).
BA3NI cells were infected with rLS-RFP (MOI = 50), and surviving cells were propagated for the next infection; this was repeated nine times (see methods). After each round, surviving cells were named with increasing cardinal numbers (i.e., BA3NI-I1 indicates those cells that survived and were expanded after one round of infection: from round 0 to 1). After every 3 rounds of infection (rounds 3, 6, and 9), subsets of selected cells were used to assess putative progression of tolerance by counting surviving cells at 72 hpi. A schematic representation of the selection process is presented in Fig. 4.
Progression of tolerance between different rounds of infection was evaluated by normalizing the survival data for each round of infection to the basal level of tolerance of the naïve cells (n values, see material and methods). BA3NI-I3 (3rd round of infection), BA3NI-I6-clone (C)1 and C2 (the two clones sorted after the 6th round of infection, see next section) and BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 (after 9th round of infection) showed increased resistance, when compared to never-infected BA3NI-I0 (n values: BA3NI-I3, 2.34 ± 0.26; BA3NI-I6-C1, 12.61 ± 1.31; BA3NI-I6-C2, 7.94 ± 1.95; BA3NI-I9-C1, 36.24 ± 20.30; BA3NI-I9-C2, 30.26 ± 7.90; mean ± SD) (Fig. 5). Using the non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis test followed by the Dunn’s test for multiple comparisons, differences in survival between BA3NI-I3 and B3NI-I9-C1 and C2 were considered to be statistically significant (p < 0.05). Representative pictures and cell counts of BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 (selected for 9 times) upon infection are showed in Fig. 6. Upon infection with rLS-RFP at MOI = 50, at 72 hpi BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 showed increased numbers of surviving cells compared to infected BA3NI-I0, as determined by microscopic evaluation (Fig. 6, panels a–f) and counting (Fig. 6, panel g). Noticeably, even as cells became progressively more tolerant to NDV infection, the virus was still able to infect the cells at each round, as shown by microscopic observation under fluorescence (Fig. 6, panels b, d).
Nine-time selected ciPSCs are devoid of NDV
After the 6th round of infection, cells became persistently infected (BA3NI-I6-PI) and continuously expressed RFP fluorescence. To select for RFP negative cells, and to continue the selection process, non-fluorescent cells were sorted (Fluorescence Activated Cells [FACs] sorting) and 2 clonally-derived cell lines were propagated (BA3NI-I6-C1 and C2) to continue the selection to the 9th round of infection (see material and methods). At the end of the selection process, non-infected BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 did not show fluorescence under microscopic observation. To confirm absence of residual NDV after the process of infection/selection, RT-PCR for NDV NP and L genes was performed on cellular RNA extracted from BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 (the clones resulted at the end of the selection process, see material and methods). Expected product size was 1306 bp and 1761 bp for NP and L gene, respectively. Results showed absence of cDNA amplicons for RNA samples extracted from BA3NI-I9-C1, C2 and BA3NI-I0 cells (Fig. 7). Expected bands were observed when RNA from BA3NI-I6-PI cells was used as template. To confirm the negative RT-PCR results, a virus isolation (VI) test was performed on BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 pellets (one passage in egg) [38, 39]. Negative results for VI (data not shown) were in agreement with the RT-PCR results, and confirmed that cells at the end of the selection process were devoid of residual virus.
Increased tolerance to virus-induced cell death in selected ciPSCs is not caused by decreased permissiveness to NDV infection
To evaluate if the increased tolerance to virus-induced cell death observed with BA3NI-I9 C1 and C2 was caused by a decreased permissiveness to NDV infection, multi-cycle growth curves were performed on BA3NI-I0 and BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 with non-virulent and virulent NDV strains rLS-RFP and rZJ1-GFP, as described previously. At 72hpi, strains rLS-RFP and rZJ1-GFP yielded higher titers in BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2, respectively, compared to BA3NI-I0 cells. At other time points (6, 12, 24, 36, 48hpi) no differences in virus yield between cell lines were observed (Fig. 8, panel a and b). These data indicate that increased tolerance of BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 cells to NDV infection was not caused by a decreased permissiveness to infection, since virus yield in BA3NI-C1 or C2 is slightly higher than in naïve cells (BA3NI-I0).
Differential gene expression between BA3NI-I0 and BA3NI-I9
RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) was used to investigate the effect of NDV selection on the BA3NI transcriptome, comparing the naïve BA3NI-I0, BA3NI-I9-C1 and BA3NI-I6-PI (persistently infected cells). Extracted RNA (in biological triplicates) for each cell line was reverse-transcribed with random priming, and sequenced using an Illumina 1.9 platform. Table 1 shows the starting and ending number of reads with the minimum average quality per sample, and the average coverage provided by each sample measured against the reference genome along with the range of read-lengths after the filtering process. Paired ends were matched, and only lengths greater than or equal to 75 nucleotides were used in the following analyses. Differential RNA expression was analyzed using the Tuxedo Suite [40–42] software, with a 0.05 significance cutoff. Results were summarized using cummeRbund software package, and false discovery rate, as implemented in Cuffdiff [41, 43], was used to correct for multiple comparisons. The analysis identified 62, 869 and 1009 differentially expressed genes between BA3NI-I0 and I6, BA3NI-I6 and I9, and BA3NI-I0 and I9, respectively (see Additional file 1: Tables S1, Additional file 2: Table S2 and Additional file 3: Table S3 for details, gene names and annotations). Pathway analysis was carried out with PathView analysis using the KEGG pathways. Significantly upregulated and downregulated pathways between comparisons are reported in Table 2.
In the present work we demonstrated the susceptibility of ciPSCs to infection with low and high virulence NDV strains, and established a selection protocol to generate ciPSCs increasingly tolerant to NDV-induced cell death. Our data demonstrated that ciPSCs can support productive infection with virulent and non-virulent NDV strains, and viral release in the supernatant to levels higher than those reached in an immortalized fibroblast cell line (DF-1). This is in agreement to what recently reported with a different ciPSC line created utilizing the same technology , suggesting that susceptibility to NDV infection in ciPSCs is likely a well-conserved feature. However, permissiveness to virus replication is a characteristic that avian stem cells may not share with other species. In fact, human and murine pluripotent stem cells were non-permissive to infection with multiple viruses, such as hepatitis C virus (HCV) , varicella zoster virus (VZV) , and only moderately permissive to Influenza A virus and human Herpes-Simplex virus-1 . At least for HCV and VZV, permissiveness to infection appeared to increase with the degree of cellular differentiation [45, 46]. This might suggest that, contrary to what observed with other viruses, NDV infection is not particularly restricted by the degree of cellular differentiation, or that chicken iPSCs have specific characteristics that are suitable for virus growth. The mechanism underlying this fast recovery of ciPSCs, in contrast to DF-1, after infection with high MOI remains to be elucidated.
Selection of ciPSCs after 9 rounds of infection allowed for the derivation of a ciPSCs line that is up to 36 times more tolerant to NDV infection than naïve ciPSCs. Despite increased tolerance, selected cells remained permissive to NDV infection. Both rLS-RFP and rZJ1-GFP grew at higher titers in 9-time selected compared to never-selected ciPSCs, possibly reflecting the higher number of cells available for virus replication at later time points. Since selected cells were still permissive to NDV replication and susceptible to the virus-induced cytopathic effect, we opted to use the operational definition of tolerance, rather than the term resistance.
The mechanisms of increased tolerance in selected cells are unclear and await further characterization. Progression of tolerance in this study was evaluated by assessing the number of cells present in the plate at 72 hpi compared to the number of cells present at the time of infection at 0 hrs. Therefore, increased tolerance can be a combination of decreased susceptibility to cell-death, or heightened recovery rate after infection, including virus clearance and replicative efficacy. Doubling time in nine-time selected ciPSCs lines, however, did not appear to be shorter compared to naïve ciPSCs (data not shown), suggesting that a faster replication is not the main mechanism leading to a more tolerant state.
RNA sequencing showed that several genes are differentially expressed between selected and non-selected cells. Pathway analysis revealed that most of the genes upregulated in BA3NI-I9-C1 included those involved in basic cellular processes, such as amino acid metabolism, cellular proliferation, apoptosis, cell adhesion and signalling, and regulation of the cytoskeleton. In agreement with our results, a recent study showed that basic cellular processes were also differentially expressed in the lungs of partially resistant Fayoumi chickens infected with AIV, when compared to fully susceptible Leghorn chickens . In particular, genes involved in actin filament-based movement and multicellular organismal process were upregulated, while those involved in cell adhesions (CAM) and immune response were downregulated .
During the selection process, ciPSCs became persistently infected after the 6th round of infection. It is possible that the high MOI used during the selection process might have led to production of defective interfering particles facilitating the establishment of a persistent infection . However, sorting of non-fluorescent cells was sufficient to rescue clones that were not persistently infected, demonstrating that increased tolerance observed with BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 cells was not the consequence of viral interference.
As they have the potential to produce chimeric and fully transgenic birds , ciPCSc that are either resistant or less susceptible to NDV infection could be used to produce transgenic birds that are resistant to ND at a cellular level. The present study is a preliminary investigation toward this direction. Our results show that increased tolerance of ciPSCs is a complex mechanism, and it is difficult to predict if this trait could be maintained through development without being silenced and be successfully passed onto offspring. Future studies should aim at inducing higher levels of resistance in selected cells, possibly using transgenic approaches where a single locus (e.g., small interfering RNA against virus genes) could confer resistance with a simpler mechanism. In this study a transgenic approach was avoided, as spontaneously resistant cells were sought through multiple selection events.
In this study, we have demonstrated that ciPSCs are susceptible to infection with high- and low-virulence NDV, and have developed a system for derivation of cell lines that are incrementally more tolerant to NDV infection through multiple rounds of infection and selection. The system described in this study could be utilized to study host mechanism of tolerance to infection against NDV in vitro, and to develop new platforms for production of disease-resistant livestock through the use iPSCs in birds and other species.
Detailed methodology for derivation of ciPSCs from CEFs are reported elsewhere . Briefly, primary chicken embryo fibroblasts from black Australorp chickens embryos were reprogrammed with Minicircle vectors expressing human transcription factors POUF51, NANOG51, SOX2, and LIN28. BA3NI cells were maintained in cKSR (knock-out serum replacement) media [DMEM/F12 (Gibco), supplemented with 20% knockout serum replacement (KSR; Gibco), 2 mM L-glutamine (Gibco), 0.1 mM nonessential amino acids (Gibco), 1xPen/strep(Gibco), 0.1 mM β-mercaptoethanol (Sigma- Aldrich), and 10 ng/mL basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF; R&D Systems)] in pre-coated plates to increase cell adhesion [Matrigel (BD Biosciences); diluted 1:100 in DMEM/F12]. For passaging, cells were dissociated with Accutase (Innovative Life Technologies). DF-1 cells (chicken fibroblast cells line - ATCC CRL 12203) were maintained in fibroblast media [Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium, high glucose (Hyclone) with 10% fetal bovine serum (Hyclone), 4 mM L-glutamine (Gibco) and 1x Pen/strep (Gibco)], and dissociated upon confluence with 0.05% trypsin. All cells were maintained at 37C and 5% CO2.
Eggs and chickens
Embryonated chicken eggs utilized for production of virus stock and virus isolation were obtained from the Southeast Poultry Research Laboratory (SEPRL) Specific Pathogen Free (SPF) white Leghorn flock.
Recombinant NDV strains ZJ1-GFP (rZJ1-GFP) and LaSota-RFP (rLS-RFP) were obtained from the SEPRL virus repository. rZJ1-GFP is a virulent strain with ICPI of 1.88 carrying the Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP) gene between the P and M genes . rLS-RFP is a lentogenic NDV with ICPI of 0.0 carrying a Red Fluorescent Protein gene between the F and the HN genes . Each virus expresses the respective fluorescent genes upon infection in cell cultures. Insertion of the extra gene cassette in the virus genomes did not induce significant decrease of virus fitness compared to parental strains, as assessed by multi-cycle growth curves in cell culture [29, 36]. To produce virus stock, viruses were inoculated in the chorioallantoic cavity of 9 to 10 day-old embryonating SPF eggs. Dead eggs, or eggs surviving after 5 days of incubation were chilled at 4 C for 24 h, and hemagglutination (HA) - positive allantoic fluid was extracted, pooled, clarified by centrifugation (10’ at 5000 rpm), and stored in 1 ml aliquots at -80C [38, 39]. Virus stock was titered in DF-1 cells in 96-well plates through limiting dilutions, and titer was expressed as Tissue Culture Infection Dose 50% (TCID50)/ml using the Spearman-Karber method .
Growth Curves in ciPSCs
To assess the ability of NDV to replicate in ciPSCs, a multi-cycle growth assay (multiplicity of infection, MOI = 0.01) was performed in BA3NI-I0 and compared to NDV replication in DF-1 cells. Additionally, growth curves were performed to compare virus growth in BA3NI-I0 and BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 after selection. Cells (BA3NI-I, BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2 and DF-1) were plated in triplicate into 6-well-plates at a density of 7×105 cells/well. After 24 h, media was discarded and cells were infected with 0.01 MOI of either rLS-RFP or rZJ1-GFP diluted in 1%-serum fibroblast media or 5% KSR media (1 ml inoculum/well), respectively for infection of DF-1 or ciPS cells. After 1 h absorption, cells were washed three times with PBS and then incubated with maintenance fibroblast or KSR media. At time points 0, 6, 12, 24, 36, 48, and 72 hpi, 200 μL of supernatant were collected and replaced with fresh media. The amount of virus in the supernatant samples was titrated in DF-1 cells using 96-well-plates through limiting dilutions, and expressed as TCID50/ml using the Spearman-Karber method . For infection with rLS-RFP, maintenance media during infection was supplemented with 8.5 μg/ml porcine trypsin (Sigma), to allow cleavage of the fusion protein and multiple cycles of infection . Concentration of trypsin was optimized in preliminary experiments to increase virus production and minimize any possible cell damage; a concentration of 8.5 μg/ml did not cause detachment or negatively affect viability of ciPSCs or DF-1 cells (data not shown).
Assessment of cytolytic effect of NDV on ciPSCs
Preliminary experiments were carried out to optimize the best conditions to assure highest levels of NDV-induced ciPSCs death. Marked cell death was observed at 72 hpi using a high MOI (=50) in combination with low cell density (initial plating density =1.6×105 cells/35-mm dish). These conditions were maintained for all the infection procedures of this work. Briefly, cells were infected in triplicate with rLS-RFP at MOI = 50, in 6-well-plate format. Cells were plated at 1.6×105 cells/well, and after 24 h cells were infected with rLS-RFP diluted in 5% KSR, as described above. After 1 h absorption, the infectious inoculum was discarded and replaced with cKSR. Three wells were used as mock-infected control and treated with 1 ml of 5% KSR without virus. Photomicrographs (Nikon Eclipse TE300, SPOT Software 5.0) were taken every 24, 48, and 72 hpi. To assess the amount of remaining cells after infection, counting was performed at 72 hpi, as follows. Wells were washed with PBS and adherent cells were dissociated with 1 ml Accutase (Innovative Cells Technologies) for 4 min at 37C. After neutralization of accutase with 1 ml of KSR media, cells were transferred in conical tubes and centrifuged at 1400 rpm for 5 min. Cell pellet was resuspended with 300 μL or 500 μL maintenance media (depending on the amount of cells), and the number of viable cells was determined with an automated cell counter (Nexcelom Bioscience Cellometer Auto T4), using 1:1 staining with 0.02% Trypan Blue solution (Sigma) for viability assessment.
Assessment of recovery after NDV infection
The ability of BA3NI, compared to DF-1, to recover after infection was assessed by counting cells at 72 and 144 hpi. BA3NI-I0 and DF-1 were plated in triplicate into 6-well plates at 1.6×105 cells/well, and after 24 h infected with rLS-RFP at MOI = 50, as described above. At the time of infection, 3 extra well for each cell line were counted and averaged to effectively calculate the exact MOI. Mock infected DF-1 and BA3NI cells were incubated with reduced serum media, as described above. At 72 and 144 hpi, 3 wells for each cell lines (both mock and infected) were counted using the Nexcelom automatic counter, as described above.
Development of a screening system to select ciPSCs after multiple rounds of infection with rLS-RFP NDV
Based on the ability of NDV to cause cytolytic effect in ciPSCs, a screening system was developed to assess the ability of ciPSCs to become incrementally tolerant to NDV upon multiple rounds of infection/selection (Fig. 4). The day before infection (D-1), BA3NI cells that were never infected previously (BA3NI-Infection (I) 0) were plated at 1.6X105 cells/well in a 6-well-plate format. The following day (time of infection, TOI, D0) cells were infected with rLS-RFP at MOI = 50, as described above. At 72 hpi (end of selection, D3), cells were washed with PBS, expanded and passaged until no observable red fluorescence was detectable under microscopic observation. Cells rescued after each round of infection were named with increasing cardinal numbers (i.e., BA3NI-I1 indicates those cells that survived and were expanded after one round of infection). Cells expanded from the previous round of infection were then plated and infected as described. Every 3 rounds of infections (rounds 3, 6, and 9) a batch of selected cells was used to assess putative progression of tolerance by counting surviving cells at 72 hpi with the Nexcelom automated counter, as described in the previous section.
Tolerance was calculated by normalizing the number of remaining infected cells at 72 hpi (D3), over the number of cells at the time of infection (D0), which was directly counted to assess the correct MOI at the time of infection. To evaluate the progression of tolerance between different rounds of infection, and to decrease inter-experimental variability, the normalized values of tolerance of BA3NI-I3, I6 and I9 derived from each experiment were divided to the normalized baseline tolerance values of the BA3NI-I0 controls that was run in parallel each time. These double-normalized values (n values) were compared between each other (Fig. 5).
Persistent infection and FAC sorting
After the 6th round of infection, BA3NI-I6 became persistently infected (PI). In order to eliminate the virus from the cell population and to proceed in the screening process, the non-fluorescent cells were separated by FAC sorting. Briefly, BA3NI-I6 cells were dissociated with Accutase, centrifuged for 5’ at 1400 rpm, and washed with PBS twice in order to obtain a final concentration of about 1×106 cells/ml. Resuspended cells in PBS were sorted using a Beckman Coulter MoFlo XDP machine, gated for non-fluorescent cells. Of the several colonies that were negative for RFP, two were expanded (BA3NI-I6-C1 and C2), and underwent the selection process through rounds 6 to 9.
RNA extraction and RT-PCR
To determine the presence of NDV in cells that underwent the whole selection process (BA3NI-I9-C1 and C2), RT-PCR for two NDV genes (NP, genomic position 43–1349; and L, genomic positions 13338–15099) was performed on total RNA. Cellular RNA was extracted as standard protocols using a phenol-chloroform system. RT-PCR was carried out using the SuperScript III One-Step RT-PCR System with Platinum Taq DNA polymerase kit (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA). Primer sequences are available upon request.
Virus isolation from ciPSCs
To determine the presence of NDV in ciPSCs that were persistently infected, and underwent 9 rounds of infection/selection, VI was performed on BA3NI-I9-C1 and BA3NI-I9-C2, using BA3NI-I0 as negative control. Cells from one confluent 100 mm dish for each cell line were harvested by dissociation with Accutase and centrifuged at 1400 rpm for 5 min after neutralization with cKSR media. Supernatant was discarded; the resulting cell pellet resuspended in 1 ml cKSR media, and the number of cells/ml was counted (Nexcelom automated counter). To free cell-associated virus, cells were freeze-thawed three times at -80C, and treated with oscillating sonicator for 2 min on ice. The homogenized pellet was used to perform virus isolation and titration in eggs, using standard methods [38, 39].
Deep Sequencing data and differential gene expression between BA3NI-I0, BA3NI-I6, and BA3NI-I9
RNA-Seq data assembly and properties
RNA was extracted in biological triplicate from 3×106 BA3NI-I0, BA3NI-I6-PI, and BA3NI-I9-C1 cells using the with RNeasy Mini kit (Qiagen), following the manufacturer protocol. RNA sample quality was assessed through a Bioanalyzer (Agilent). RNA libraries were created from each RNA sample, as follows. Starting with total RNA, first strand cDNA amplification was performed using Oilgo(dT) oligomers. A cDNA library was then created using random hexamer primers, and millions of short DNA reads were generated by sequencing the RNA samples in individual lanes of an Illumina 1.9 instrument (Illumina) by the University of Georgia Genomic Facility. Data were preprocessed by first trimming the first 15 nucleotides from each of the 5’ end of each of the reads and then using a sliding window of size 3 and an average quality of 25 to trim both ends of the reads. This was followed by a filtering step to remove reads such that 80% or more nucleotides within a read had a quality score greater than 20. FastQC was used to examine the quality of the reads before and after trimming and indicates that on average all of the retained reads were of average quality greater than 19 for all samples. Paired end were matched and only lengths greater than or equal to 75 nucleotides were used in the following analyses.
RNA-Seq analysis of differential expression
The Tuxedo Suite [41–43] was used to evaluate the transcriptome of BA3NI-I0, BA3NI-I6-PI, and BA3NI-I9 with one sample obtained for each condition. All reads were aligned to the Chicken (Gallus Gallus) genome obtained from http://useast.ensembl.org/info/data/ftp/index.html (last accessed July 29th 2016). The protocol for differential gene expression analysis was published elsewhere . Briefly, we first built the indexed genome using bowtie 2. Then, utilizing this genome and the annotated genes, we first aligned the Illumina sequences using TopHat 2 and assessed differential expression using Cufflinks 2 (significance, p < 0.05). We used the commeRbund package in R for visualization and further analysis.
Differences between mean n values were analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test followed by the Dunn’s test for multiple comparisons. Virus titers and cell counts over time were analyzed using a two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) for repeated measures followed by a Tukey’s or Sidak’s test for multiple comparisons. All tests were considered statistically significant for p values < 0.05. Statistical analysis was carried out using GraphPad Prism for iOS, version 7 (GraphPad Software, La Jolla California USA).
Analysis of variance
Chicken induced pluripotent stem cells
Days post infection
Hours post infection
Induced pluripotent stem cells
Multiplicity of infection
Newcastle disease virus
Afonso C, Miller PJ. Newcastle Disease: Progress and Gaps in the development of Vaccines and Diagnostic Tools. In: Roth J, Ritch JA, Morozov IA, editors. Vaccines and Diagnostics for Transboundary Animal Diseases Volume. Basel: Karger; 2013. p. 95–106.
Lamb R, Collins PL, Kolakofsky D, Melero JA, Nagay Y, Oldstone MBA, et al. The negative sense single stranded RNA viruses. In: Fauquet CM, Mayo MA, Maniloff J, Desselberg U, Ball LA, editors. Virus taxonomy. San Diego: Elsevier Academic Press; 2005. p. 607–738.
Miller PJ, Kock G, Suarez D, Mundt E, Jones RC, Rautenschlein S. Newcastle Disease, Other Avian Paramyxoviruses, and Avian Metapneumovirus Infections. In: Swayne DE, Glisson JR, McDougald LR, Nolan LK, Suarez DL, Nair V, editors. Diseases of Poultry. 13th ed. Ames: Blackwell Publishing; 2013. p. 89–138.
Anonymous. Newcastle disease (Infection with Newcastle disease virus). In: OIE World Organization for Animal Health, editor. Manual of diagnostic tests and vaccines for terrestrial animals. 6th edition. Paris: OIE; 2012. p. 555–574.
Miller PJ, Afonso CL, El Attrache J, Dorsey KM, Courtney SC, Guo Z, Kapczynski DR. Effects of Newcastle disease virus vaccine antibodies on the shedding and transmission of challenge viruses. Dev Comp Immunol. 2013;41:505–13.
Kapczynski DR, Afonso CL, Miller PJ. Immune responses of poultry to Newcastle disease virus. Dev Comp Immunol. 2013;41:447–53.
Miller PJ, Kim LM, Ip HS, Afonso CL. Evolutionary dynamics of Newcastle disease virus. Virology. 2009;391:64–72.
Herrmann MS GR, Bunn DA, Zhou H, Lamont SJ: Do Two Distinct Chicken Lines Differ in Their Response to Newcastle Disease Virus? In Animal Industry Report; 2016
Takahashi K, Yamanaka S. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from mouse embryonic and adult fibroblast cultures by defined factors. Cell. 2006;126:663–76.
Takahashi K, Tanabe K, Ohnuki M, Narita M, Ichisaka T, Tomoda K, Yamanaka S. Induction of pluripotent stem cells from adult human fibroblasts by defined factors. Cell. 2007;131:861–72.
Wu Y, Zhang Y, Mishra A, Tardif SD, Hornsby PJ. Generation of induced pluripotent stem cells from newborn marmoset skin fibroblasts. Stem Cell Res. 2010;4:180–8.
West FD, Terlouw SL, Kwon DJ, Mumaw JL, Dhara SK, Hasneen K, Dobrinsky JR, Stice SL. Porcine induced pluripotent stem cells produce chimeric offspring. Stem Cells Dev. 2010;19:1211–20.
Rossello RA, Chen CC, Dai R, Howard JT, Hochgeschwender U, Jarvis ED. Mammalian genes induce partially reprogrammed pluripotent stem cells in non-mammalian vertebrate and invertebrate species. Elife. 2013; 2:e00036.
Lu Y, West FD, Jordan BJ, Mumaw JL, Jordan ET, Gallegos-Cardenas A, Beckstead RB, Stice SL. Avian-induced pluripotent stem cells derived using human reprogramming factors. Stem Cells Dev. 2012;21:394–403.
Lu Y, Mumaw JL, West FD, Stice SL. Livestock induced pluripotent stem cells. Reprod Domest Anim. 2012;47 Suppl 4:72–6.
Yu P, Lu Y, Jordan BJ, Liu Y, Yang JY, Hutcheson JM, Ethridge CL, Mumaw JL, Kinder HA, Beckstead RB, Stice SL, West FD. Nonviral minicircle generation of induced pluripotent stem cells compatible with production of chimeric chickens. Cell Reprogram. 2014;16(5):366–78.
O'Connor MD, Kardel MD, Iosfina I, Youssef D, Lu M, Li MM, Vercauteren S, Nagy A, Eaves CJ. Alkaline phosphatase-positive colony formation is a sensitive, specific, and quantitative indicator of undifferentiated human embryonic stem cells. Stem Cells. 2008;26:1109–16.
West FD, Uhl EW, Liu Y, Stowe H, Lu Y, Yu P, Gallegos-Cardenas A, Pratt SL, Stice SL. Brief report: chimeric pigs produced from induced pluripotent stem cells demonstrate germline transmission and no evidence of tumor formation in young pigs. Stem Cells. 2011;29(10):1640–3.
Lu Y, West FD, Jordan BJ, Jordan ET, West RC, Yu P, He Y, Barrios MA, Zhu Z, Petitte JN, Beckstead RB, Stice SL. Induced pluripotency in chicken embryonic fibroblast results in a germ cell fate. Stem Cells Dev. 2014;23(15):1755–64.
Sun Q, Zhao L, Song Q, Wang Z, Qiu X, Zhang W, Zhao M, Zhao G, Liu W, Liu H, et al. Hybrid- and complex-type N-glycans are not essential for Newcastle disease virus infection and fusion of host cells. Glycobiology. 2012;22:369–78.
Sun Y, Ding N, Ding SS, Yu S, Meng C, Chen H, Qiu X, Zhang S, Yu Y, Zhan Y, Ding C. Goose RIG-I functions in innate immunity against Newcastle disease virus infections. Mol Immunol. 2013;53:321–7.
Fournier P, Wilden H, Schirrmacher V. Importance of retinoic acid-inducible gene I and of receptor for type I interferon for cellular resistance to infection by Newcastle disease virus. Int J Oncol. 2012;40:287–98.
Wang J, Basagoudanavar SH, Wang X, Hopewell E, Albrecht R, Garcia-Sastre A, Balachandran S, Beg AA. NF-kappa B RelA subunit is crucial for early IFN-beta expression and resistance to RNA virus replication. J Immunol. 2010;185:1720–9.
Aoki K, Oh-hira M, Hoshino M, Kawakita M. Isolation and characterization of a novel mutant mouse cell line resistant to Newcastle disease virus: constitutive interferon production and enhanced interferon sensitivity. Arch Virol. 1994;139:337–50.
Zhang Y, Fu D, Chen H, Zhang Z, Shi Q, Elsayed AK, Li B. Partial antiviral activities detection of chicken Mx jointing with neuraminidase gene (NA) against Newcastle disease virus. PLoS One. 2013;8:e71688.
Li B, Fu D, Zhang Y, Xu Q, Ni L, Chang G, Zheng M, Gao B, Sun H, Chen G. Partial antiviral activities of the Asn631 chicken Mx against newcastle disease virus and vesicular stomatitis virus. Mol Biol Rep. 2012;39:8415–24.
Yin CG, Zhang CS, Zhang AM, Qin HW, Wang XQ, Du LX, Zhao GP. Expression analyses and antiviral properties of the Beijing-You and White Leghorn myxovirus resistance gene with different amino acids at position 631. Poult Sci. 2010;89:2259–64.
Wagner RR. Viral interference. Some considerations of basic mechanisms and their potential relationship to host resistance. Bacteriol Rev. 1960;24:151–66.
Li J, Hu H, Yu Q, Diel DG, Li DS, Miller PJ. Generation and characterization of a recombinant Newcastle disease virus expressing the red fluorescent protein for use in co-infection studies. Virol J. 2012;9:227.
Thacore H, Youngner JS. Cells persistently infected with newcastle disease virus: I. Properties of mutants isolated from persistently infected L cells. J Virol. 1969;4:244–51.
Hara T, Endo T, Furukawa K, Kawakita M, Kobata A. Elucidation of the phenotypic change on the surface of Had-1 cell, a mutant cell line of mouse FM3A carcinoma cells selected by resistance to Newcastle disease virus infection. J Biochem. 1989;106(2):236–47.
Kimura Y, Yokochi T, Miyadai T, Yoshida K, Yokoo J, Matsumoto K. Characterization of a porcine kidney cell line resistant to influenza virus infection. J Virol. 1985;53:980–3.
Hertzler S, Trottier M, Lipton HL. Selection and characterization of a BHK-21 cell line resistant to infection by Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus due to a block in virus attachment and entry. J Gen Virol. 2000;81:2485–90. Haines KM, Vande.
Burgt NH, Francica JR, Kaletsky RL, Bates P. Chinese hamster ovary cell lines selected for resistance to ebolavirus glycoprotein mediated infection are defective for NPC1 expression. Virology. 2012;432:20–8.
Dezengrini R, Weiblen R, Flores EF. Selection and characterization of canine, swine and rabbit cell lines resistant to bovine viral diarrhea virus. J Virol Methods. 2006;137:51–7.
Liu YL, Hu SL, Zhang YM, Sun SJ, Romer-Oberdorfer A, Veits J, Wu YT, Wan HQ, Liu XF. Generation of a velogenic Newcastle disease virus from cDNA and expression of the green fluorescent protein. Arch Virol. 2007;152:1241–9.
Himly M, Foster DN, Bottoli I, Iacovoni JS, Vogt PK. The DF-1 chicken fibroblast cell line: transformation induced by diverse oncogenes and cell death resulting from infection by avian leukosis viruses. Virology. 1998;248:295–304.
Alexander DJ, Senne DA. Newcastle disease and other avian paramyxoviruses. In: Dufour-Zavala L, Swayne DE, Glisson JR, Jackwood MW, Pearson JE, Reed WM, Woolcock PR, editors. A laboratory manual for the isolation, identification and characterization of avian pathogens. 4th ed. Athens: American Association of Avian Pathologists; 2008. p. 135–41.
McGinnes LW, Pantua H, Reitter J, Morrison TG: Newcastle disease virus: propagation, quantification, and storage. Curr Protoc Microbiol 2006, Chapter 15:Unit 15 F 12.
Trapnell C, Williams BA, Pertea G, Mortazavi A, Kwan G, van Baren MJ, Salzberg SL, Wold BJ, Pachter L. Transcript assembly and quantification by RNA-Seq reveals unannotated transcripts and isoform switching during cell differentiation. Nat Biotechnol. 2010;28:511–5.
Trapnell C, Pachter L, Salzberg SL. TopHat: discovering splice junctions with RNA-Seq. Bioinformatics. 2009;25:1105–11.
Langmead B, Salzberg SL. Fast gapped-read alignment with Bowtie 2. Nat Methods. 2012;9:357–9.
Trapnell C, Roberts A, Goff L, Pertea G, Kim D, Kelley DR, Pimentel H, Salzberg SL, Rinn JL, Pachter L. Differential gene and transcript expression analysis of RNA-seq experiments with TopHat and Cufflinks. Nat Protoc. 2012;7:562–78.
Shittu I, Zhu Z, Lu Y, Hutcheson JM, Stice SL, West FD, Donadeu M, Dungu B, Fadly AM, Zavala G, et al. Development, characterization and optimization of a new suspension chicken-induced pluripotent cell line for the production of Newcastle disease vaccine. Biologicals. 2016;44:24–32.
Wu X, Robotham JM, Lee E, Dalton S, Kneteman NM, Gilbert DM, Tang H. Productive hepatitis C virus infection of stem cell-derived hepatocytes reveals a critical transition to viral permissiveness during differentiation. PLoS Pathog. 2012;8:e1002617.
Dukhovny A, Sloutskin A, Markus A, Yee MB, Kinchington PR, Goldstein RS. Varicella-zoster virus infects human embryonic stem cell-derived neurons and neurospheres but not pluripotent embryonic stem cells or early progenitors. J Virol. 2012;86:3211–8.
Wash R, Calabressi S, Franz S, Griffiths SJ, Goulding D, Tan EP, Wise H, Digard P, Haas J, Efstathiou S, Kellam P. Permissive and restricted virus infection of murine embryonic stem cells. J Gen Virol. 2012;93:2118–30.
Wang Y, Lupiani B, Reddy SM, Lamont SJ, Zhou Z. RNA-seq analysis revealed novel genes and signaling pathway associated with disease resistance to avian influenza virus infection in chickens. Poult Sci. 2014;93:485–93.
Hierholzer JC Killington RA. Virus Isolation and Quantification. In: Mahy WJB and O Kangro H, editors. Virology Methods Manual. London: Academic Press; 1996. p 35–39.
Nagai Y, Klenk HD, Rott R. Proteolytic cleavage of the viral glycoproteins and its significance for the virulence of Newcastle disease virus. Virology. 1976;72:494–508.
We would like to acknowledge Dawn Williams-Coplin, Tim Olivier, and Erin P. Jordan for their outstanding technical support.
This research was supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (Global Development Grant Number 0PP1019226) and the Agricultural Research Service and Current Research Information System of the US Department of Agriculture (6040-32000-064).
Availability of data and materials
LS, design of the study, collection and assembly of data, statistical analysis, data analysis and interpretation, manuscript writing. YH, cell maintenance and collection of data. JHM, cell maintenance and collection of data. YL, design of the study, data analysis, assisted in BA3NI derivation. FDW, conception and design of the study, data analysis and interpretation, manuscript writing. SLS, conception and design of the study, collection and assembly of data, data analysis and interpretation. PY, collection and assembly of data, derivation of BA3NI. ZA, RNA-seq analysis. CLA, conception and design of the study, collection and assembly of data, data analysis and interpretation. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors have no competing interests to report.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
List of differentially expressed genes between BA3NI-I0 and BA3NI-I6 (average of biological triplicates). (XLSX 57 kb)
List of differentially expressed genes between BA3NI-I6 and BA3NI-I9-C1 (average of biological triplicates). (XLSX 189 kb)
List of differentially expressed genes between BA3NI-I0 and BA3NI-I9-C1 (average of biological triplicates). (XLSX 214 kb)