Differential pathogenicity of two different recombinant PVYNTN isolates in Physalis floridana is likely determined by the coat protein gene
Virology Journal volume 8, Article number: 207 (2011)
A previous study has identified two types of recombinant variants of Potato virus Y strain NTN (PVYNTN) in China and sequenced the complete genome of the variant PVYNTN-HN2. In this study, the complete genome of isolate PVYNTN-HN1 was fully sequenced and analyzed. The most striking difference between the two variants was the location of recombinant joint three (RJ3). In PVYNTN-HN1, like other typical European-PVYNTN isolates such as PVYNTN-Hun, the RJ3 was located at nucleotide (nt) 9183, namely the 3' proximal end of the CP gene (nt. 8571-9371), thus leading to most (the first 613 nucleotides from the 5' proximal end) of the CP gene (801 bp) with a PVYN origin and PVYN-serotype; whereas in contrast, the RJ3 in PVYNTN-HN2 was located at nt 8572, consequently leading to a CP gene of PVYO origin and PVYO-serotype. The varied genome composition among PVYO, PVYN, PVYN:O, PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYNTN-HN2 made them useful for the investigation of possible roles of gene segment(s) in symptom formation on host plants. When Physalis floridana plants were infected with different PVY isolates, two types of symptoms were induced. PVYN and PVYNTN-HN1 induced mild symptoms (mainly mild mottling) whereas PVYO, PVYN:O and PVYNTN-HN2 induced serve symptoms including leaf and stem necrosis, leaf-drop and stunting. These results, together with a previous study using artificial PVY chimeras, demonstrate that the CP gene, especially the 5' proximal segment (nt 8572-9183), and/or CP likely determine the pathogenicity of PVY in P. floridana.
Potato virus Y (PVY) is the type species of the Potyvirus genus in the Potyviridae family . It infects a number of plant species in the nightshade family (Solanaceae) and causes a wide range of symptoms from symptomless to mosaic, mottling, lesions, stunting, necrosis and plant death, depending on the plant species, the cultivar, the virus strain and isolate . PVY possesses a single-stranded positive RNA genome comprised of approximately 9700 nucleotides that encode a polyprotein of approximately 3061 amino acids . The polyprotein undergoes proteolysis to form 10 mature proteins with different functions including replication, transportation and spread of the virus [1, 2]. Many strains/substrains of PVY have been recognized according to the primary hosts and host reactions. For the potato-infecting PVY, the ordinary strain (PVYO), the tobacco veinal necrosis strain (PVYN) and the potato stipple streak strain (PVYC) are the first ones to be recognized , followed by the potato tuber necrosis strain (PVYNTN) and the recombinant N:O/Wilga group (PVYN:O or PVYN-Wilga) [3–5]. PVYNTN is characterized by its ability to induce potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD) in sensitive potato cultivars [5–7], whereas PVYN:O is defined by its reaction to PVYO-specific antibody (i.e., PVYO-serotype) but causing veinal necrosis on tobacco plants (i.e., PVYN pathotype) [5, 8]. Two types of PVYNTN, one recombinant and the other non-recombinant, have been identified [4, 7, 9]. The former is represented by PVYNTN-Hun  and has been referred to as European (Eu)-PVYNTN[7, 11–13], and the latter is represented by PVYNTN-Tu 660  and has been referred to as North American (NA)-PVYNTN[7, 11, 12, 14]. Both Eu-PVYNTN and NA-PVYNTN react to PVYN-specific antibody [11, 13]. Recently, a new recombinant PVYNTN variant type has been identified in Syria [15, 16] and China . The variant type that includes the isolates PVYNTN-NW and PVYNTN-HN2  reacts to PVYO-antibody and induces veinal necrosis on tobacco and PTNRD on sensitive potato cultivars [9, 16]. Reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) based genotyping has been successfully used to characterize the genome features of the Eu-PVYNTN-like isolate PVYNTN-HN1 and the PVYNTN-NW-like isolate PVYNTN-HN2 in China . Here we report the differential responses of Physalis floridana to PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYNTN-HN2 infections. PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYN induced mottling on P. floridana whereas PVYNTN-HN2, PVYO and PVYN:O induced severe symptoms including leaf and stem necrosis, leaf-drop and stunting. The results, together with the genome make-ups of various PVY isolates, suggest that the CP gene plays a significant role in symptom induction in P. floridana, consistent with the results reported by Bukovinszki et al..
The greenhouse maintained PVY isolates PVYNTN-HN1 (formerly PVY sample 1 ), PVYNTN-HN2, PVYN-Jg, PVYO-RB and PVYN:O-Mb58 in 'Russet Burbank' plants/tubers [5, 7, 9, 11–13] were used in this study. PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYNTN-HN2 were obtained in China , while the rest were from Canada [5, 7, 11–13]. All isolates have been characterized molecularly by P1 gene- and recombinant joint (RJ)-based RT-PCR assays [12, 13], pathologically by tobacco- and potato-based bioassays, and serologically by PVYO- and PVYN-antibody-based ELISA assays [5, 7, 9, 11–13, 18]. Moreover, except for PVYNTN-HN1, all of the isolates have been sequenced fully (PVYNTN-HN-2, PVYN-Jg, PVYO-RB) or partially (PVYN:O-Mb58) (accession numbers are HM367076, AY166867, GQ200836, AY745493 for PVYO-RB, PVYN-Jg, PVYNTN-HN-2, and PVYN:O-Mb58 respectively). To better understand the isolate PVYNTN-HN1, especially to reveal the exact nucleotide locations of the recombinant joints that had been detected by RT-PCR , the complete genome of PVYNTN-HN1 was sequenced. The same nine sets of PCR primers (for primer sequences, see reference ) that had been used to clone/sequence various isolates of PVY [5, 7, 9, 18] were used. Each primer pair resulted in a DNA fragment of 1.0 to 1.3 kb, overlapping with adjacent fragments with approximately 100 bp at each end. Each fragment was cloned into a pGM-T cloning vector (TIANGEN Biotech, Beijing, China) according to the manufacturer's instructions; and two clones of each fragment were sequenced from both forward and reverse directions using the universal T7 promoter and SP6-promoter primers at the Sangon Biological Engineering Technology & Services Co. Ltd (Shanghai, China). The complete genome sequence (GenBank accession number HQ631374) was confirmed by re-sequencing overlapping cDNA clones obtained from a separate experiment from RNA isolated from PVYNTN-HN1 infected tobacco leaves. Sequence identities were analyzed using BLAST (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/BLAST). For detection of the recombinant events, complete nucleotide sequences of various PVY isolates were aligned using ClustalW2 (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/clustalw2/index.html) . The aligned sequences served as inputs for similarity scanning using the program SimPlot [20, generously provided by the author at http://sray.med.som.jhmi.edu/]. The resulting similarities were plotted along the nucleotide sequences of the virus genome.
As anticipated, PVYNTN-HN1 shared highest sequence identities with PVYNTN-Hun, a representative of typical Eu-PVYNTN, at both complete nucleotide and polyprotein levels at 99.2% and 99.1%, respectively. It was followed by PVYNTN-HN2/PVYNTN-NW, PVYN:O, PVYN and PVYO, represented by isolates PVYNTN-HN2, PVYN:O-Mb112, PVYN-N605 and PVYO-RB, respectively (Table 1). The sequence identities between PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYN-Jg, a NA- PVYN[7, 11], were 90.9% and 95.9% at the complete nucleotide and polyprotein levels, respectively (Table 1). As expected, the sequence identities between PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYN:O-Mb58 (accession number AY745493, partial length) were similar to that between PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYN:O-Mb112 (data not shown). Further comparison of PVYNTN-HN1 with PVYNTN-HN2 at mature protein level revealed that the two shared high sequence identities for all proteins (97.8 - 100%) but the CP (Table 1), which was similar to that exhibited in PVYNTN-Hun vs PVYNTN-HN2 . Sequence screening of PVYNTN-HN1 against PVYO (e.g., PVYO-RB) and PVYN (e.g., PVYN-605 or PVYN-Jg) using SimPlot  revealed three recombinant joints at nt 2419, 5844 and 9183 in PVYNTN-HN1 genome (Figure 1D), resulting from the genome recombination between PVYN and PVYO. In contrast, the RJs in PVYNTN-HN2 were located at nt 2521, 5867 and 8572 (Figure 1D) . PVYNTN-HN1 shares identical RJs with PVYNTN-Hun (data not shown). The location of RJ3 in PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYNTN-Hun at nt 9183, namely the 3' proximal end of CP gene (nt 8571-9371), led to most (the first 613 nt from the 5' proximal end) of the 801-bp-long CP gene of a PVYN origin, which eventually resulted in a PVYN-serotype of these isolates [5, 7, 9]. In contrast, the RJ3 in PVYNTN-HN2/PVYNTN-SYR-NB-16N (accession number AB270705) at nt 8572, namely the 5'end of the CP gene, led to the complete CP gene of a PVYO origin, which further resulted in a PVYO-serotype [9, 15]. One RJ, namely RJ1, was present in PVYN:O isolates including PVYN:O-Mb112 and PVYN:O-Mb58 at nt 2397  (Figure 1D), resulting in a recombinant genome in which the segment prior to the RJ was from PVYN and the remainder from PVYO.
Previous study has revealed the pathotypes of PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYNTN-HN2 on tobacco and potato . To further characterize the biological properties of these isolates, and, moreover, to investigate whether the different RJ3 sites, namely different CP gene types, play a role in symptom induction in different plant species, tobacco (cv. 'Samsun'), potato (cv. 'Yukon Gold') and Physalis floridana plants were mechanically inoculated with PVYNTN-HN1, PVYNTN-HN2, PVYN-Jg, PVYO-RB, and PVYN:O-Mb58 as described previously . Mock (buffer)-inoculated plants were used as a healthy control. As shown in Figure 1A, petiole and stem necrosis occurred on tobacco plants 15 days after inoculation with PVYN-Jg, PVYN:O-Mb58, PVYNTN-HN1 or PVYNTN-HN-2. Veinal necrosis also developed on these plants. On the other hand, the PVYO-infected plants only developed mosaic symptoms on the leaves and were free of veinal, petiole and stem necrosis (Figure 1A). No symptoms were observed on the mock-inoculated plants. Various studies have indicated that HC-Pro plays an important role in necrosis development on tobacco plants [5, 21, 22]. All isolates but PVYO-RB possessed a PVYN-type of HC-Pro gene [5, 7, 9, 18] (Figure 1D), and therefore induced PVYN-like symptoms including veinal/petiole/stem necrosis on tobacco plants. When inoculated to 'Yukon Gold' plantlets (5-leaf-stage), the isolates induced varied foliar symptoms including mild mottling (PVYN-Jg), mosaic (PVYN:O-Mb58) and severe mosaic/stunting/leaf deformation (PVYO-RB, PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYNTN-HN2) (data not shown), consistent with the previous report . No visible symptoms were observed on potato tubers produced from plants infected with PVYN-Jg, PVYO-RB or PVYN:O-Mb58; and in contrast, distinct necrotic ringspots were observed on potato tubers harvested from plants infected with PVYNTN-HN1 or PVYNTN-HN2 (Figure 1B), thus confirming that both types of recombinant PVYNTN isolates are capable of inducing PTNRD in sensitive potato cultivars.
It has been known that PVYO induces necrosis in Physalis floridana, whereas PVYN incites mottling in this species . Using N/O hybrids comprised of the chimeric genome of PVYN-N605  and PVYO, the symptom formation on P. floridana due to PVY infection was mapped to the CP gene region . Because of the varied genome compositions among the isolates (Figure 1D), they could be used to investigate the putative role of genome segment(s) of PVY in symptom development on P. floridana, as done on tobacco [5, 24]. Severe symptoms including leaf and stem necrosis, leaf-drop and stunting were observed on P. floridana plants infected with PVYO-RB, PVYN:O-Mb58 and PVYNTN-HN2 three weeks after inoculation (Figure 1C), and as time progressed, the symptoms became more distinct. The isolate PVYN:O-Mb58 led to plant death five weeks after the inoculation. On the other hand, mild symptoms, mainly mottling, were observed on PVYN-Jg and PVYNTN-HN1 infected P. floridana plants (Figure 1C). Taken together, it can be concluded that the CP gene originated from PVYO is likely responsible for the severe symptoms in PVYO-, PVYN:O- or PVYNTN-HN2-infected P. floridana plants. These results, together with the results obtained using artificial PVY chimeras , demonstrate that the CP gene, especially the 5' proximal segment (nt 8572-9183) of the gene, plays a critical role in symptom formation in P. floridana upon PVY infection, and determines the pathoginicity of PVY isolates. The 3' proximal segment of NIb gene (nt 8136-8570) does not appear to be involved in the symptom formation in P. floridana as suggested by Bukovinszki et al.. It is also noteworthy that the different symptoms incited by different PVY types/isolates in tobacco, potato and P. floridana can be used to uncover the genome compositions of the virus.
Shukla DD, Ward CW, Brunt AA: The Potyviridae. Wallingford, Oxon, UK: CAB International; 1994.
Riechmann JL, Laín S, García JA: Highlights and prospects of potyvirus molecular biology. J Gen Virol 1992, 73: 1-16. 10.1099/0022-1317-73-1-1
Chrzanowska M: New isolates of the necrotic strain of potato virus Y (PVYN) found recently in Poland. Potato Res 1991, 34: 178-182.
Glais L, Tribodet M, Kerlan C: Genomic variability in Potato potyvirus Y (PVY): evidence that PVYNW and PVYNTNvariants are single to multiple recombinants between PVYOand PVYNisolates. Arch Virol 2002, 147: 363-378. 10.1007/s705-002-8325-0
Nie X, Singh RP, Singh M: Molecular and pathological characterization of N:O isolates of the Potato virus Y from Manitoba, Canada. Can J Plant Pathol 2004, 26: 573-583. 10.1080/07060660409507178
Le Romancer M, Kerlan C, Nedellec M: Biological characterization of various geographical isolates of potato virus Y inducing superficial necrosis on potato tubers. Plant Pathol 1994, 43: 138-144. 10.1111/j.1365-3059.1994.tb00563.x
Nie X, Singh RP: Evolution of North American PVYNTNstrain Tu 660 from local PVYNby mutation rather than recombination. Virus Genes 2003, 26: 39-47. 10.1023/A:1022326021195
Singh RP, McLaren DL, Nie X, Singh M: Possible escape of a recombinant isolate of Potato virus Y by serological indexing and methods of its detection. Plant Dis 2003, 87: 679-685. 10.1094/PDIS.2003.87.6.679
Hu X, He C, Xiao Y, Xiong X, Nie X: Molecular characterization and detection of recombinant isolates of Potato virus Y from China. Arch Virol 2009, 154: 1303-1312. 10.1007/s00705-009-0448-z
Thole V, Dalmay T, Burgyan J, Balazs E: Cloning and sequencing of potato virus Y (Hungarian isolate) genomic RNA. Gene 1993, 123: 149-156. 10.1016/0378-1119(93)90118-M
Nie X, Singh RP: Probable geographical grouping of PVYNand PVYNTNbased on sequence variation in P1 and 5'-UTR of PVY genome and methods for differentiating North American PVYNTN. J Virol Methods 2002, 103: 145-156. 10.1016/S0166-0934(02)00023-X
Nie X, Singh RP: A new approach for the simultaneous differentiation of biological and geographical strains of Potato virus Y by uniplex and multiplex RT-PCR. J Virol Methods 2002, 104: 41-54. 10.1016/S0166-0934(02)00037-X
Nie X, Singh RP: Specific differentiation of recombinant PVYN:Oand PVYNTNstrains by multiplex RT-PCR. J Virol Methods 2003, 113: 69-77. 10.1016/S0166-0934(03)00221-0
Piche LM, Singh RP, Nie X, Gudmestad NC: Diversity among Potato virus Y isolates obtained from potatoes grown in the United States. Phytopathology 2004, 94: 1368-1375. 10.1094/PHYTO.2004.94.12.1368
Chikh Ali M, Maoka T, Natsuaki KT: The occurrence and characterization of new recombinant isolates of PVY displaying shared properties of PVYNWand PVYNTN. J Phytopath 2007, 155: 409-415. 2007 10.1111/j.1439-0434.2007.01251.x
Chikh Ali M, Maokac T, Natsuakib T, Natsuaki KT: PVYNTN-NW, a novel recombinant strain of Potato virus Y predominating in potato fields in Syria. Plant Pathol 2010, 59: 31-41. 10.1111/j.1365-3059.2009.02174.x
Bukovinszki A, Gotz R, Johansen E, Maiss E, Balazs E: The role of the coat protein region in symptom formation on Physalis floridana varies between PVY strains. Virus Res 2007, 127: 122-125. 10.1016/j.virusres.2007.03.023
Nie B, Singh M, Sullivan A, Singh RP, Xie C, Nie X: Recognition and molecular discrimination of severe and mild PVYOvariants of Potato virus Y in potatoes in New Brunswick, Canada. Plant Dis 2011, 95: 113-119. 10.1094/PDIS-04-10-0257
Larkin MA, Blackshields G, Brown NP, Chenna R, McGettigan PA, McWilliam H, Valentin F, Wallace IM, Wilm A, Lopez R, Thompson JD, Gibson TJ, Higgins DG: ClustalW and ClustalX version 2. Bioinformatics 2007, 23: 2947-2948. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btm404
Lole KS, Bollinger RC, Paranjape RS, Gadkari D, Kulkarni SS, Novak NG, Ingersoll R, Sheppard HW, Ray SC: Full-length human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genomes from subtype C-infected seroconverters in India, with evidence of intersubtype recombination. J Virol 1999, 73: 152-160.
Tribodet M, Glais L, Kerlan C, Jacquot E: Characterization of Potato virus Y (PVY) molecular determinants involved in the vein necrosis symptom induced by PVYNisolates in infected Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi. J Gen Virol 2005, 86: 2101-2105. 10.1099/vir.0.80926-0
Hu X, Meacham T, Ewing L, Gray SM, Karasev AV: A novel recombinant strain of Potato virus Y suggests a new viral genetic determinant of vein necrosis in tobacco. Virus Res 2009, 143: 68-76. 10.1016/j.virusres.2009.03.008
Jakab G, Droz E, Brigneti G, Baulcombe D, Malnoe P: Infectious in vivo and in vitro transcripts from a full-length cDNA clone of PVY-N605, a Swiss necrotic isolate of potato virus Y. J Gen Virol 1997, 78: 3141-3145.
Ramírez-Rodríguez V, Aviña-Padilla K, Frías-Treviño G, Silva-Rosales L, Martínez-Soriano J: Presence of necrotic strains of Potato virus Y in Mexican potatoes. Virology J 2009, 6: 48. 10.1186/1743-422X-6-48
The research was supported by the Ministry of Science and Technology of China under the project # 20073346 to XX and CH and by Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada (AAFC) under the projects #50 and #1389 to XN. XH was a receipt of the Ministry of Education of China-AAFC Ph.D. Student Internship Program (2007-2008); XN is an adjunct professor at Hunan Agricultural University.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
XH carried out the experiments. XN designed, analyzed and wrote the paper. HC and XX collected isolates PVYNTN-HN1 and PVYNTN-HN2, participated in experiment planning and execution. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Hu, X., Nie, X., He, C. et al. Differential pathogenicity of two different recombinant PVYNTN isolates in Physalis floridana is likely determined by the coat protein gene. Virol J 8, 207 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1186/1743-422X-8-207