Evidence that spontaneous reactivation of herpes virus does not occur in mice

Background Some species, including humans and rabbits, exhibit periodic viral reactivation and shed infectious virus at the infected end organ. Mice may be an exception, because spontaneous shedding of infectious virus rarely, if ever, occurs. However, spontaneous molecular reactivation, i.e., the expression of a few viral genes and the synthesis of the viral glycoproteins coded for by these genes, has been reported. This finding has prompted the assumption that molecular reactivation is an indicator of reactivation and the production of infectious virus. The goal of this study was to differentiate between viral gene expression during latency and the episodic production of infectious virus in mice. Results Viral reactivation and infection were not seen in herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) latent ganglion graft recipient BALB/c scid or immunocompetent BALB/c mice, which survived the 65-day observation period with no evidence of viral infection although the immunocompetent mice developed cellular and humoral immunity to HSV-1. In contrast, BALB/c scid recipients of ganglia containing reactivating virus invariably developed a local and, subsequently, systemic viral infection and died within 14 days. Immunocompetent BALB/c mice that received ganglion grafts containing reactivating virus survived the infection and became immune to the virus. Trigeminal ganglia removed from scid and immunocompetent recipient graft sites 5, 14, and 28 days after transplantation contained latent virus and viable neurons. Conclusion The results suggest that, within the limits of detection of the experiments, spontaneous episodic production of immunogenic viral antigens but not of infectious virus occurs in mouse neural ganglia during latency.


Background
The infectious cycle of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) in experimental animals is similar to that which occurs in humans, but there may be a significant difference as well. HSV-1 readily infects epithelial surfaces of most mammalian species, replicates in these cells, enters the nervous system, and achieves a latent state in neurons in the peripheral nervous system. A notable species difference is that the virus undergoes spontaneous, episodic reactivation with or without evidence of recurrent disease in humans and rabbits, whereas mice either do not undergo spontaneous reactivation or undergo spontaneous reactivation at such a low frequency that it is difficult to document [1].
Testing an end organ such as the eye or the site of viral latency, the sensory ganglia, for infectious virus during latency in mice fails to yield virus [2][3][4][5]. However, evidence of viral gene expression in the trigeminal ganglia of mice during latency has been reported [6,7]. In addition to the expression of the latency-associated transcript (LAT), the expression of other viral genes and their products has been found in a small number of ganglion cells. Feldman et al. [8] described "abundant" expression of viral genes and proteins and noted viral DNA synthesis in occasional neurons. This process was termed "spontaneous molecular reactivation"; no evidence of infectious virus was reported in this study [8].
Stevens and Cook [3] transplanted ganglia from latent mice into mice that were actively immunized with irradiated virus or passively immunized with anti-HSV antibody and concluded that antiviral antibody helped maintain viral latency. Tenser et al. [4] reported that viral reactivation occurred in ganglion transplants after ex vivo explantation. The occurrence of secondary latency was proposed as a consequence of viral reactivation and infection of "secondary" neurons in the grafts; however, infectious virus was not found in ganglion homogenates [4].
The current study was designed to differentiate between viral gene expression and the production of infectious virus in latent mouse ganglia in vivo. The experimental system was designed to assess for the production of small numbers of infectious viral particles which would lead to morbidity and, ultimately, mortality in the host mice. In the results reported here, molecular reactivation (i.e., expression of HSV-1 genes and production of glycoproteins during latency) did not proceed to the production of detectable infectious virus in immune-deficient mice. The results suggest that viral reactivation does not occur spontaneously and episodically in the mouse trigeminal ganglion in vivo.

Absence of infectious virus in the trigeminal ganglion during latency
Infectious virus was present on the ocular surface and in both trigeminal ganglia of a group of five BALB/c mice sacrificed 5 days after topical ocular infection (Table 1). On days 10,20,30,50,70, and 100 after infection, both the ocular surface and the trigeminal ganglion homogenates of latently infected mice failed to yield infectious virus as evidenced by cytopathic effect on Vero cells ( Table  1).

Sensitivity of the ganglion assay
Assay of trigeminal ganglion homogenates for infectious virus immediately after microinjection of a known number of PFU of virus revealed that the limit of sensitivity for the in vitro assay was between 50 and 100 PFU per ganglion ( Table 2). All ganglia injected with 100 PFU yielded plaques and 6 of 10 ganglia injected with 50 PFU yielded plaques ( Table 2). Injection of smaller numbers of PFU did not reproducibly yield plaques (Table 2).
Ten out of 10 of the BALB/c scid mice receiving ganglia injected with 100 PFU and 9 of 10 mice receiving ganglia injected with 50 PFU died from complications of viral pathogenesis within 12 days of receiving ganglion transplants ( Table 3). Five of 10 BALB/c scid mice receiving ganglion grafts containing 10 PFU and 1 of 10 mice receiving grafts containing 5 PFU died within 14 days of receiving the grafts ( Table 3). None of the 10 animals receiving the ganglion grafts containing 1 PFU gave evidence of viral infection and viral pathogenesis over a 35-day observation period.

Outcome of ganglion transplantation Acute protocol
Results from three replicate experiments revealed that the BALB/c scid recipients of ganglion transplants from acutely infected BALB/c donors transplanted 3 days after infection (N = 19) all died, with a mean time to death of 14 days and a standard deviation of ± 2 days (Fig. 1). In contrast, all of the immunocompetent BALB/c recipients of acutely infected ganglia (N = 15) survived (Fig. 1).
The cause of death in the BALB/c scid mice was not extensively examined in this study. As the animals became progressively moribund, it was evident that they were experiencing a neurological disease resembling encephalitis. In randomly chosen animals, virus was isolated from the ear graft site at the time that the animal died. Confirmation that virus was replicating at the transplant site is provided below. Eye 5/5 b 0/5 0/5 0/5 0/5 0/5 0/5 Trigeminal ganglia 10/10 0/10 0/10 0/10 0/10 0/10 0/10 a Infected mice (N = 5) were killed and eye swabs (both combined) and trigeminal ganglion homogenates (separately) tested for infectious virus. b The numbers indicate number of eye swabs and trigeminal ganglion homogenates containing infectious virus/number of each tested at each time.

Latent protocol
In a series of three experiments involving a total of 100 recipients (70 BALB/c scid, 30 immunocompetent BALB/ c), only 1 of the 70 BALB/c scid recipients of a latent ganglion transplant died (28 days after grafting). Virus was not isolated from the graft site or the brain of this animal. As shown in Figure 2, the remainder of the BALB/c scid recipients survived without evidence of viral infection up to 65 days after grafting. All of the 30 immunocompetent BALB/c recipients of latent ganglion transplants survived for the duration of the experiment (Fig. 2). Mice in both of these groups were bled at 21, 45, and 65 days after grafting to test their sera for anti-HSV-1 antibodies, as described below.

Reactivation protocol
Ganglia from BALB/c mice latent for HSV-1 were passaged in tissue culture for 3 days and then transplanted into BALB/c scid recipients (N = 24) and immunocompetent BALB/c recipients (N = 16). All of the BALB/c scid recipients developed viral infections and viral-mediated neurologic disease and died, with a mean time to death of 14 days (Fig. 3). Analyses of the transplanted tissue and the local graft site supported the conclusion that the cause of death was the reactivated virus. In contrast, all of the immunocompetent BALB/c recipients of reactivated gan-   glia survived without evidence of disease ( Fig. 3) and ultimately became immune to the virus.

Serum anti-HSV-1 antibody responses in ganglion recipients
None of the BALB/c scid recipients of latently infected ganglia developed a serum IgG antibody response as measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Randomly chosen BALB/c scid mice tested at 21, 45, and 65 days after transplantation showed no evidence of having developed a humoral immune response to the virus (Fig. 4a). The BALB/c mice that received latent ganglion transplants did not exhibit an anti-HSV-1 antibody response on day 21 after transplantation, but had serum antibody on days 45 and 65 after grafting (Fig. 4a). The immunocompetent BALB/c recipients of acutely infected ganglia or of ganglia containing reactivating virus developed serum antibody IgG responses by 21 days after infection, which were present also at 45 and 65 days after transplantation (Fig. 4b).

Cell-mediated immunity in ganglion transplant recipients
BALB/c scid mice from the Latent Protocol that survived the 65-day observation period were tested by footpad swelling assay. None of the animals tested gave evidence of a delayed-type hypersensitivity response to viral antigens (Fig. 5). In contrast, all of the immunocompetent BALB/c recipients of acutely infected ganglia and recipients of ganglia undergoing viral reactivation exhibited delayed-type hypersensitivity responses on day 65 after ganglion transplantation (Fig. 5). Four of seven immunocompetent BALB/c recipients of latent ganglia also had positive delayed-type hypersensitivity responses on day 65 after transplantation ( Fig. 5).

Viability of the ganglion transplants
Latent ganglia that had been transplanted into BALB/c scid and immunocompetent BALB/c recipients were removed from the graft recipients on days 5, 14, or 28 after transplantation and placed into tissue culture. Seventeen of 18 latent ganglia removed from BALB/c scid animals underwent reactivation in vitro (Table 4), typically within 3 to 6 days after explantation. All of the latent ganglia recovered from immunocompetent BALB/c recipients underwent reactivation in tissue culture between days 6 and 10 after explantation.
The histology of ganglion transplants was examined on days 5, 28, and 65 after transplantation. Although the architecture of transplanted ganglia was somewhat altered compared with that of freshly isolated ganglia ( numerous large cells with the morphology of neurons were seen in latent ganglia transplanted to BALB/c scid (Fig. 6b) and immunocompetent BALB/c (Fig. 6c) recipients. Table 5 presents the results of the vital dye staining of cells isolated from ganglion transplants. Viable small (nonneuronal) and large (neurons) cells were found in roughly the same ratios on days 5, 14, 28, and 65 after transplantation. These ratios were similar to the ratios of small and large cells obtained from freshly isolated ganglia ( Table  5).
Confirmation that viral reactivation and viral glycoprotein synthesis was occurring in ganglia transplanted during acute infection and in ganglia transplanted following reactivation was obtained by performing immunohistochemical staining for HSV-1 antigens in tissue sections.
Staining of viral antigens was seen in the ganglion transplants and adjacent ear cells in BALB/c scid recipients of acutely infected (Fig. 7a) and reactivating (Fig. 7b) ganglia, but not in recipients of latent ganglion transplants (Fig. 7c).

Discussion
The results of these experiments indicate that little, if any, infectious virus is produced during latency in mice. It has been proposed that some component of the immune system is necessary to induce HSV-1 into latency and prevent viral reactivation [9][10][11][12][13][14][15]. Sawtell [16] reported that immune cells in mouse ganglia do not inhibit viral reactivation. Thus, the role of antiviral immunity in the establishment and maintenance of latency is still being debated.
The immunocompetent BALB/c mice in the acute, latent, and reactivation protocols developed cellular and humoral immunity, indicating that there was an adequate amount of viral antigen produced in all three circumstances to sensitize the recipients. The finding that T cellmediated and humoral responses developed and were sustained for 65 days suggests that viral antigen expression during latency has a role in this process. BALB/c scid mice lack an acquired immune system but have an intact innate immune system, including cells such as macrophages and natural killer (NK) cells and antiviral cytokines such as the types 1 and 2 interferons. NK cells alone cannot protect scid mice from HSV-1 infection and pathogenesis [17]. However, protection against viralmediated death can be provided by T lymphocytes [18][19][20][21]. There is ample evidence to indicate that the interferons modulate the level of viral replication and spread, although this response is not known to protect scid mice from HSV-1-mediated death [22][23][24]. However, in the absence of an acquired immune system and, in particular, T lymphocytes, the virus evades the interferon response, enters the nervous system, and replicates in vital cells causing a fatal encephalitis.
The findings of the current study appear to imply that mouse neural tissue containing latent HSV-1 (e.g., the trigeminal ganglion) does not support periodic episodic viral reactivation. Although spontaneous molecular viral reactivation has been reported [8], the results presented here suggest that this molecular reactivation does not proceed to the production of detectable infectious virus. It may be that there are nonimmunological cellular or molecular factors that prevent spontaneous viral reactivation in mice.
These findings in vivo are particularly important since it is known that explanted mouse neural tissues latent for HSV-1 demonstrate viral reactivation in culture. This suggests that explantation itself or factors in tissue culture that we do not understand may suppress or destroy the in vivo factors that maintain viral latency.
A number of reports describe the induction of viral reactivation from latency in mice using a variety of stimuli such as immunosuppressive drugs, UV irradiation, and thermal stress [25][26][27][28][29]. These induction protocols yield a variable frequency of viral reactivation. There are no reports confirming spontaneous episodic shedding of virus at epithelial surfaces of mice, including the eye and genitalia, although it has been reported recently that infectious virus is present in the trigeminal ganglion up to 240 days after infection [16].
The possibility that the surgical trauma of ganglion transplantation or the site in which the transplant was placed (the ear) prevents viral reactivation from occurring and/or prevents infectious virus from leaving this site to infect the animal's nervous system must be considered. However, in the Acute and Reactivation Protocol mice, it was found

Conclusion
It is concluded that measurable infectious virus is not produced under the conditions of these experiments. Thus, the technical approach used here appears to be a valid and sensitive measure of the presence of infectious virus. The results of this study reveal that molecular reactivation, i.e., expression of HSV-1 genes and production of glycoproteins during latency, occurs in mice and extends this observation to establish that molecular reactivation does not necessarily lead to the production of infectious viral particles. The approach used in this investigation opens up new vistas for studying herpesvirus latency and reactivation.

Mice
Female BALB/cJ and BALB/c scidJ mice at 5 weeks of age (The Jackson Laboratory, Bar Harbor, ME) were used. Confirmation that the BALB/c scid mice were immune deficient was achieved by performing flow cytometric analysis of spleen cells for CD3 + T cells and membrane immunoglobulin-positive cells. No evidence of the presence of T or B lymphocytes in the BALB/c scid mice sacrificed throughout the course of this study was obtained (data not shown). Animals studies were approved by the Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC). All animals were provided with food and water ad libidum and were cared for according to the NIH Guidelines on the Care and Use of Animals in Research.

Virus
The McKrae strain of HSV-1, a strain which is known to spontaneously reactivate in rabbits, was propagated in and titered on Vero cells (American Type Culture Collection, Manassas, VA). At the time of infection, the virus stock was thawed and diluted so as to deliver 1 × 10 5

Analysis of the trigeminal ganglion for infectious virus during latency
Thirty-five BALB/c strain mice were infected with the McKrae strain of HSV-1 by the topical ocular route as described above. Five days after infection, the eyes of all animals were swabbed for the determination of infectious virus. Also on day 5, five animals were killed and their trigeminal ganglia were separately homogenized in 0.5 ml of tissue culture medium. The ganglion homogenates were tested for infectious virus on Vero cell monolayers in 24well tissue culture plates. In this experiment, no attempt was made to quantitate infectious virus, but only to note the presence or absence of infectious virus in the ganglia. Eye swabs and trigeminal ganglion homogenates were similarly tested from five additional animals killed at each of the following time points: 10, 20, 30, 50, 70, and 100 days after infection.

Determination of the sensitivity of the assay for infectious virus in the ganglion
Groups of 10 uninfected BALB/c mice were sacrificed and their trigeminal ganglia removed intact and placed into tissue culture medium. The 20 ganglia from each group of mice were positioned under a stereoscopic microscope and each ganglion injected with a 5 µl volume of culture medium containing 100, 50, 10, 5, or 1 PFU of the McKrae strain of HSV-1. Ten ganglia from each group were immediately homogenized in 0.5 ml of culture medium, the homogenate clarified by centrifugation at 8000 × g in a microcentrifuge, and the supernatant plated on Vero cells in 24-well plates. Following viral attachment, the supernatant was removed and a 0.5% methylcellulose overlay was placed in each well. The plates were incubated for 2 days and plaques counted. The remaining 10 ganglia  (81) a Ganglion grafts or freshly isolated ganglia were dissociated and stained with vital DNA dye and trypan blue. The total numbers of small cells (10-50 µm) and large cells (larger than 50 µm), as well as the number of live cells in each size category, were determined by microscopic examination. b Number of viable cells of each size/total number of cells of each size counted (%).
were transplanted into subcutaneous ear pockets in BALB/ c scid mouse recipients as described below. The mice were observed daily for signs of viral pathogenesis and death.

Ganglion transplantation
Recipient mice were anesthetized with a mixture of ketamine and xylazine and positioned under a stereoscopic dissecting microscope such that the entire ear pinna could be seen at 10× magnification. The tip of the ear was gently grasped with sterile forceps and an incision made in the dorsal skin surface with a sterile lamellar blade (Wilson Ophthalmic, Mustang, OK). The lamellar blade was gently eased below the surface of the epithelium with a sideto-side and insertion-retraction motion, creating a pocket Immunohistochemical staining for viral antigens

ELISA for serum antibody
Serum was collected from the BALB/c and BALB/c scid animals at the time of sacrifice. ELISA plates were coated with a cell culture lysate from Vero cells infected 18 hours previously with McKrae strain HSV-1. This lysate contains a mixture of HSV-1 antigens and has been used in previous studies [30,31]. Equal numbers of ELISA plate wells were coated with a cell culture lysate of uninfected Vero cells. The plate wells were washed three times with Tris buffered saline (TBS) and 1:50 dilutions of each serum were tested in quadruplicate for reactivity with the infected and uninfected cell lysates. Binding of serum anti-HSV antibody was detected with a secondary rabbit anti-mouse IgG antibody coupled to horseradish peroxidase (Jackson ImmunoResearch Laboratories, Inc., West Grove, PA). Following washing, the plate wells were incubated in tetramethylbenzidine substrate (DakoCytomation, Inc., Carpinteria, CA) for 15 minutes at room temperature and the reaction stopped with 1 M sulfuric acid. The optical densities were read at 450 nm in a plate reader and the optical density values for each serum sample tested on the infected cell lysate were corrected by subtraction of the optical density obtained with the serum on the uninfected cell lysate.

Footpad swelling assay for delayed type hypersensitivity
The same infected cell lysate used to coat the ELISA plates was treated with UV light for 10 minutes to inactivate infectious virus. Mice were anesthetized with a mixture of ketamine and xylazine. The left hind footpads were injected with 10 µl of the treated, infected lysate and the right hind footpad received 10 µl of the uninfected cell lysate. At 24 hours, the footpad swelling response was measured using a spring-loaded micrometer gauge (Starett, Inc., Athol, MA). Four measurements were made of each right and left footpad. Delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions were calculated as follows: specific footpad swelling = (24 hr measurement of left footpad -0 hr measurement of left footpad) -(24 hr measurement of right footpad -0 hr measurement of right footpad) × 10 3 mm. In each experiment, in addition to the test animals, mice not immune to HSV-1 and mice immunized with UV-inactivated virus were used as negative and positive controls.

Histology and immunohistochemical staining
Animals selected at random were sacrificed and the portion of the ear containing the ganglion transplant site was frozen and sectioned in a cryotome. The sections (10 µm) were placed on microscope slides and fixed in cold acetone for 5 minutes. Representative sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin for histopathologic examination. Additional sections were stained for cells expressing HSV-1 antigens. A direct staining method employing a polyclonal, horseradish peroxidase-conjugated rabbit anti-HSV-1 antibody (DakoCytomation) was used. The antibody was diluted 1:200 in TBS containing 1% bovine serum albumin. Following incubation for 1 hour, the slides were washed in three washes of TBS for 5 minutes each and then incubated in the substrate consisting of diaminobenzidine and hydrogen peroxide (Pierce Biotechnology, Inc., Rockford, IL). Color development was stopped after 5 minutes and the sections were counterstained with methyl green. Control slides were incubated in an irrelevant peroxidase-labeled rabbit antibody followed by the substrate.

Cell viability in ganglion transplants
Transplanted ganglia were removed from ear pockets at 5, 14, 28, and 65 days after transplantation. Each ganglion was teased apart with forceps in 2 ml of calcium/magnesium-free Hank's balanced salt solution (GIBCO) containing 10 U DNase, 0.1 mg/ml dispase, 0.1 mg/ml collagenase, and 0.1 mg/ml trypsin. The tissue fragments were incubated with gentle stirring for 15 minutes at 37°C. The cells and tissue clumps were gently triturated and washed two times in DMEM/10% FBS. The cells were resuspended in 2 ml DMEM/10% FBS containing 1 µg/ml of Hoechst 33342 vital DNA stain (H342, Calbiochem, La Jolla, CA) for 15 minutes at 37°C. The cells were washed twice in DMEM/FBS and resuspended in 2 ml of medium. Living and dead cells were differentiated with the addition of 0.1% trypan blue, which quenches the H342 fluorescence of dead cells [32]. The cells were placed onto clean microscope slides, coverslipped, and immediately examined on a Nikon E600 fluorescence microscope with a UV-2E/C (330-380 excitation; 435-485 barrier) filter. The cells were categorized as either small (10-50 µm in diameter, non-neurons) or larger than 50 µm in diameter (neurons). For each suspension, 10 microscopic fields at 100× magnification were examined, and the total number of cells, the numbers of small and large cells, and the numbers of fluorescing (i.e., not quenched, viable) cells in each of the two size ranges were determined.

Statistical analysis
Analysis of numerical data and statistical analyses were performed with Microsoft Excel (Redmond, WA), Modstat (Modern Microcomputers, Mechanicsville, VA), and CoStat (Cohort Software, Monterey, CA). Fisher's exact test was used to compare the differences in survival frequencies between groups of mice. P values less than 0.01 were considered significant.
Publish with Bio Med Central and every scientist can read your work free of charge